Skip to main content

LegalReports

Law School & Bar Course Case Library

Ernst & Young LLP v Capital Markets Authority

Court of Appeal of Kenya (Nairobi) · 6 December 2019 · Civil Appeal No. 92 of 2017; [2019] eKLR

Highlight

Additional evidence will only be admitted on appeal if it could not have been obtained earlier with reasonable diligence, is credible, and would probably have an important influence on the result. Ernst & Young's bid to bring in new evidence of bias by the Capital Markets Authority failed because it rested on belief, not proof.

You can open and download 10 more cases free of charge. Subscribe for unlimited access

AI Summary · Awaiting editorial review

Brief facts

The Capital Markets Authority issued Ernst & Young a notice to show cause over its audit of Uchumi Supermarkets. Ernst & Young's constitutional petition, alleging the Authority would act as investigator, prosecutor and judge, was dismissed by the High Court. On appeal it applied to adduce additional evidence: cases where the Authority had delegated hearings to independent organs under section 11A, and a judgment in a suit by a former senior employee who had since joined the Authority.

Issues

Whether the appellant met the threshold for leave to adduce additional evidence on appeal under Rule 29(1)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules.

Decision

Application dismissed with costs.

Reasoning

The court admits fresh evidence on appeal only in exceptional circumstances: the evidence must be credible, unavailable at trial despite reasonable diligence, and likely to have an important influence on the outcome. The appellant laid no foundation for its claim that the former employee was involved in the show cause proceedings; he joined the Authority after they began. Without that link, the evidence could not influence the appeal and there was no factual basis for alleging bias.

Legal issues this case answers

error: You aren't allowed to copy this content! Thank you!