Skip to main content

LegalReports

Law School & Bar Course Case Library

ALTX East Africa Ltd v Capital Markets Authority

High Court of Uganda (Civil Division) · 28 February 2020 · Miscellaneous Cause No. 426 of 2019

Highlight

A regulator may only cancel a licence on grounds and through a process the Capital Markets Act actually provides. The Capital Markets Authority acted illegally and unfairly when it cancelled ALTX East Africa's approval to operate a securities exchange, so the cancellation was quashed by certiorari.

You can open and download 10 more cases free of charge. Subscribe for unlimited access

AI Summary · Awaiting editorial review

Brief facts

ALTX East Africa Ltd held the Capital Markets Authority's approval to operate a securities exchange in Uganda. After a notice to show cause citing, among other things, inconsistencies in share capital and inadequate accounting systems, the Authority cancelled the approval by notice of 20 November 2019. ALTX had asked for the notice to show cause to be withdrawn, but the Authority never decided on that request. ALTX applied for certiorari, prohibition, mandamus, an injunction and damages.

Issues

1. Whether the decision cancelling the approval to operate a securities exchange was made in accordance with the law.
2. What remedies are available to the parties.

Decision

Application allowed. Certiorari issued quashing the cancellation of ALTX's approval to operate a securities exchange (letter of 20 November 2019). No damages were awarded because no loss was proved. Costs to the applicant.

Reasoning

Judicial review looks at the decision-making process, not the merits. Powers must be used only for the purposes for which the statute confers them; using them outside that purpose is ultra vires and arbitrary. The public interest test the Authority relied on sets a very high bar, requiring clear abuse with a broader impact on the capital markets, which was not shown. The Authority also breached ALTX's legitimate expectation of fair treatment by never deciding its request to withdraw the notice to show cause or giving reasons. Damages are not automatic in judicial review: an applicant must prove a recognisable wrong and actual loss.

Legal issues this case answers

error: You aren't allowed to copy this content! Thank you!