Skip to main content

LegalReports

Law School & Bar Course Case Library

Republic v Capital Markets Authority

High Court of Kenya (Nairobi) · 9 April 2018 · Miscellaneous Civil Application No. 62 of 2016

Highlight

Before taking adverse action, a regulator must give the affected person adequate notice and supply the material it will rely on; the duty is on the regulator, not the person, to ask for it. The Capital Markets Authority's enforcement action against Uchumi's former CEO was quashed for breach of fair administrative action.

You can open and download 10 more cases free of charge. Subscribe for unlimited access

AI Summary · Awaiting editorial review

Brief facts

Jonathan Irungu Ciano, former CEO of Uchumi Supermarkets, was dismissed in 2015. A KPMG forensic audit reported malpractice at Uchumi. The Capital Markets Authority held proceedings and on 17 November 2016 issued a notification of enforcement action against him. He said he received the KPMG report only on the eve of his appearance before the Board, and sought certiorari and prohibition.

Issues

Whether the Capital Markets Authority's proceedings and decision met the threshold of fair administrative action under section 4(3) of the Fair Administrative Action Act.

Decision

Application allowed. Certiorari quashed the notification of enforcement action of 17 November 2016 and prohibition restrained the Authority from acting on it. Any fresh process must strictly follow the law. No order as to costs.

Reasoning

A notice must be clear, not vague, should point to the legal provision relied on and the consequences of non-compliance, and must not read as if the decision has already been made. The law places on the administrator the duty to furnish the person with the information, materials and evidence to be relied on; it is not for the person to ask. The Authority's handling of the KPMG report fell short of section 4(3)(a) and (g). Costs were denied because the applicant could have sought an adjournment.

Legal issues this case answers

error: You aren't allowed to copy this content! Thank you!